DutchCraft (Ohio) is an Amish-handcrafted rent-to-own mattress line. The Troyer family has built it in Orwell, Ohio since 2017. You'll find it at rent-to-own dealers such as Rent-2-Own. The 15-inch VanBuren plush pillowtop and the double-sided Eisenhower 2.0 suit lease-to-own shoppers who want thick hybrid comfort. Your biggest caveat is that the brand doesn't publish a warranty, a sleep trial or customer reviews (checked September 2026).
Good fit: rent-to-own shoppers using dealers like Rent-2-Own; fans of Amish-handcrafted double-sided and flippable builds; plush pillowtop lovers (VanBuren); shoppers wanting thick 15-inch hybrids without paying full price upfront. Poor fit: shoppers needing a published sleep trial, warranty terms, or verified reviews; online-checkout DTC buyers; strict-organic or latex-only shoppers; buyers wanting full spec sheets before purchase.
Outside review scores
Review sites checked: Not yet researched. Their scores: Not yet researched. Model they tested: Not yet researched. Each site tests in its own way, so read each row on its own.
DutchCraft (Ohio) is the Amish-handcrafted rent-to-own mattress line built by the Troyer family in Orwell, Ohio since 2017 and sold through RTO dealers such as Rent-2-Own. The 15-inch VanBuren plush pillowtop and the double-sided Eisenhower 2.0 suit lease-to-own shoppers wanting thick hybrid comfort. Biggest caveat: no published warranty, sleep trial, or customer reviews as of Sept 2026.
Orwell, Ohio
Made in
Troyer family, since 2017
Built by
Not yet researched
Not yet researched
When DutchCraft makes sense
Rent-to-own shoppers using dealers like Rent-2-Own
Fans of Amish-handcrafted double-sided and flippable builds
Plush pillowtop lovers (VanBuren)
Shoppers who want thick 15-inch hybrids without paying full price upfront
When Another Mattress May Suit You Better
Shoppers who need a published sleep trial, warranty terms or verified reviews
Online-checkout buyers
Strict-organic or latex-only shoppers
Buyers who want full spec sheets before purchase
Review site scores
How the big review sites score DutchCraft
Each site's own score and the exact bed it tested, side by side.
Scroll sideways to see the whole table
Publication
Reported Score
Configuration Tested
Testing Scope
Evaluation Focus
Main configuration: Not yet researched. Read each row's testing scope before comparing scores. Each outlet uses its own method, so we don't combine these scores into one rating.
Reading the scores
Why we don't average the scores
Use the dates and sources shown with each result. Prices, models and policies can change.
Chapter 02
Comfort and firmness: which mattress fits you
Why this matters to you: Feel names are the brand's words, not measurements. Use them to shortlist two or three beds, then let your body decide.
Side sleepers: the VanBuren plush pillowtop with HyPURGel and nano coils is the closest fit for pressure relief; firmness ratings not published. Back sleepers: the Eisenhower 2.0 double-sided with lumbar copper foam and an 8-inch coil unit. Stomach sleepers: the Eisenhower 2.0 flipped to its firmer side is the closest guess; firmness not published.
Hot sleepers: the VanBuren cool-touch cover and copper-infused foams, though no comparative cooling data is published. Lease-to-own budget shoppers: the VanBuren and Eisenhower 2.0 at $25/week Queen. All guidance is inferred from layer names since comfort and firmness ratings are not published.
Firmness finder
Which DutchCraft feel fits you?
Weight chart not yet researched
Weight and sleep position can change how a bed feels. We have not yet checked whether DutchCraft publishes a fit chart by body weight, so use a trial, where one is offered, to test the bed the way you sleep at home.
Neck: on your side, your nose should line up with the middle of your chest, not tip up or down.
Shoulders: your bottom shoulder should sink in. Tingling or a numb arm means the bed is too firm for you.
Lower back: on your back, slide a flat hand under your waist. A big gap means too firm; no room at all can mean too soft.
Hips: ask someone to look from the side. Hips lower than shoulders means the bed is too soft for you.
Figure 2.1: Four checks to run in a store, lying still in the position you sleep in most. The store test in chapter 11 says how long to lie on each bed.
Chapter 03
Compare the mattresses
Why this matters to you: Models from one brand can differ in feel, height and layers. Match the feel label and height to how you sleep before you compare prices.
DutchCraft lists 5 models. Feel names are the brand's labels.
VanBuren Luxury Plush Pillowtop: 15-inch plush pillowtop hybrid; cool-to-touch stretch knit cover; 1-inch copper quilt foam; 1-inch firm quilt foam; 1-inch nano coil unit; 2-inch HyPURGel gel foam; 1-inch HD luxury firm foam; Quantum Edge individually encased coils; 1-inch firm base foam; Queen R2O retail $1,120 ($25/week; $99.99/month; 78 weeks); Twin ($20/week), Full ($23/week), King ($30/week) per R2O brand page.
Eisenhower 2.0 Double-Sided: 15-inch luxury double-sided and flippable six-layer build marketed as Amish Built; copper performance quilt foam (1 inch); copper lumbar support foam (1/2 inch); support foams (1.75 inch and 1/2 inch); 8-inch coil system with reinforced edge support; Queen R2O retail $1,120 ($25/week; $99.99/month; 78 weeks); Full ($23/week) and King ($30/week) per R2O brand page.
Obsidian Pillow Top: listed on the R2O DutchCraft brand page at $35/week (Queen); factory site suggests a $2,499 retail price; layer specs not published as of Sept 2026. Factory-site siblings: Eisenhower Plush (suggested retail $1,899) and Autumn Breeze (suggested retail $1,399); specs not published as of Sept 2026 and likely RTO-channel counterparts of the models above.
Scroll sideways to see the whole table
Visual
Model
Build
Profile
Firmness (brand words)
Queen $
V
VanBuren Luxury Plush Pillowtop
Plush pillowtop hybrid
15 inches
Plush pillowtop
$1,120
E
Eisenhower 2.0 Double-Sided
Double-sided flippable
15 inches
Double-sided and flippable, firmness not published
$1,120
Obsidian Pillow Top
Layer specs aren't published.
Not yet researched
Pillowtop
$35/week
Eisenhower Plush
Factory-site sibling to the Eisenhower 2.0. Specs aren't published.
Not yet researched
Plush
Suggested retail $1,899
Autumn Breeze
Factory-site model. Specs aren't published.
Not yet researched
Not yet researched
Suggested retail $1,399
Where the maker doesn't publish a number, we say so.
Scroll sideways to see the whole table
Model
Coil gauge
Coil count
Foam density
Latex
ILD
Model 1 of 5
VanBuren Luxury Plush Pillowtop: Not yet researched
V
VanBuren Luxury Plush Pillowtop
VanBuren Luxury Plush Pillowtop, product photo
ConstructionPlush pillowtop hybrid
Profile15 inches
FirmnessPlush pillowtop
Queen $$1,120
Not yet researchedNot yet researched
Hybrid with a cool-to-touch stretch knit cover, 1 in copper quilt foam, 1 in firm quilt foam, a 1 in nano coil unit and 2 in HyPURGel gel foam. It also has 1 in HD luxury firm foam, Quantum Edge individually encased coils and 1 in firm base foam.
FirmnessDouble-sided and flippable, firmness not published
Queen $$1,120
Not yet researchedNot yet researched
Six-layer Amish Built luxury build with 1 in copper performance quilt foam and 1/2 in copper lumbar support foam. It has support foams of 1.75 in and 1/2 in, plus an 8 in coil system with reinforced edge support.
Prices checked Not yet researched · recheck before buying
Mattress prices and value
Why this matters to you: A starting price can rise with size, base and delivery. Get the full price for your size in writing before you choose.
R2O rent-to-own pricing (Sept 2026): VanBuren Queen retail $1,120 at $25/week or $99.99/month over 78 weeks (about $1,950 total); Eisenhower 2.0 Queen identical at $25/week with $1,120 retail; Obsidian Queen $35/week. Size ladder per R2O brand page: Twin from $20/week; Full $23/week; King $30/week. Factory suggested retails: Autumn Breeze $1,399; Eisenhower Plush $1,899; Obsidian Pillow Top $2,499.
Value read: thick 15-inch Amish-built hybrids with copper and specialty foams at midrange retails, but true value is hard to judge because warranty, trial, and independent reviews are unpublished and the RTO total cost substantially exceeds retail.
Not yet researched
White-glove delivery, setup, and old-mattress removal are covered in Delivery & Setup.
Prices and sales discounts come from current brand catalogs. Prices may change during holiday promotions.
Are the expensive ones worth it?
Scroll sideways to see the whole table
Model
Buy DutchCraft If
Skip If
Buy Instead
Chapter 05
How well do the mattresses hold up?
Why this matters to you: A mattress is a long buy. Lean on the written warranty and real owner reports to judge how it will last.
No independent durability, sag, or longevity testing published as of Sept 2026. Indirect signals: the double-sided Eisenhower 2.0 can be flipped to distribute wear; Quantum Edge and reinforced edge coils plus firm base foam are marketed for lifespan; Amish hand-tufting and handcrafting heritage (20-plus years; Troyer family Ohio factory since 2017). Warranty terms that would signal expected life: not published as of Sept 2026.
What to watch for, and when:
Ownership, deals, lawsuits & launches
Company History & Model Evolution
Show the full company history
2017Troyer family factory in Orwell, Ohio
built by the Troyer family in Orwell, Ohio since 2017
Each milestone comes from the brand's own pages, government and court records, or named news reports, each with the date we checked it. Factory suppliers may update minor parts over time.
What we could confirm, and what the brand doesn't say
The left column is what we checked. Rows marked THE BRAND SAYS only report what the brand says. The right column is what the brand doesn't publish. Use the right column as your list of questions for a store or the brand's chat.
Scroll sideways to see the whole table
What we checked
What the brand doesn't publish
THE BRAND SAYSDouble-sided Eisenhower 2.0 can be flipped
NOT PUBLISHEDNo independent durability testing published
THE BRAND SAYSReinforced edge coils and firm base foam
NOT PUBLISHEDNo warranty terms published
THE BRAND SAYSNot yet researched
NOT PUBLISHEDNo foam density or coil count published
THE BRAND SAYSNot yet researched
NOT PUBLISHEDNot yet researched
Where sources disagree
Chapter 06
Sleep trials, returns, exchanges and fees
Why this matters to you: Feel is hard to judge in a store or in a week. Know your exit plan and its cost before you pay.
No brand-level sleep trial, return, exchange, or restocking-fee policy is published on the factory site or R2O product pages as of Sept 2026. RTO purchases follow the store lease agreement (78-week term shown); early-buyout, return, and exchange rights are set by the local dealer. Get trial, exchange, and fee terms in writing before signing.
Trial length: not published as of Sept 2026.
Your trial, night by night
Not yet researchedNot yet researched
Not yet researchedNot yet researched
Not yet researchedNot yet researched
What each choice costs you
Keep it$0Nothing more to do
Return itNot yet researchedNot yet researched
Swap itNot yet researchedNot yet researched
Not covered by the trial: Not yet researched
Figure 6.1: The trial in three dates and three prices. Put the last date in your calendar the day the bed arrives.
Check the terms for your seller and order date before buying from DutchCraft.
Chapter 07
Delivery, setup and old-mattress removal
Why this matters to you: Delivery terms decide your first week with the bed. Confirm the date, setup and old-bed removal before you pay.
R2O advertises FREE Delivery plus Service with same-day delivery on its product pages; contact the local R2O for terms, exclusions apply. Old-mattress removal, setup fees, and haul-away terms: not published as of Sept 2026. The DutchCraft Ohio factory states it can roll pack and ship Amish handcrafted mattresses anywhere in the United States from Orwell, Ohio; dealer-arranged freight timing and fees: not published as of Sept 2026.
Typical wait: Not yet researched
Figure 7.1: What happens between your order and your first night. Clear a path to the bedroom before the team arrives.
Confirm the delivery date, setup and removal terms for your address before ordering.
Chapter 08
Terms checked on the brand's site · recheck before you buy
What do the warranties cover?
Why this matters to you: A warranty is only as good as its terms. Read the written terms and use a supported base, because the wrong frame can end coverage.
No warranty page, warranty card, coverage term, sag or impression threshold, or claim process is published on the factory site or R2O product pages as of Sept 2026. What is and is not covered, prorating, and whether coverage travels with the lease or the owner: not published as of Sept 2026. Ask the dealer for the written warranty and keep the receipt and law tag.
Covered when the dip is deeper than Not yet researched, measured with nobody on the bed.
Strip the bed down to the mattress and wait a few hours so the top layers can recover.
Lay a straight edge (a broom handle or long level) across the dip, resting on the flat parts.
Measure from the edge down to the deepest point, then photograph the ruler for your claim.
Figure 8.1: How to measure a sag before you file a warranty claim. Drawing not to scale.
Chapter 09
Review counts checked on each site · they change daily
Customer reviews and complaints
Why this matters to you: Star ratings depend on who posts and where. Read the low-star reviews for patterns, not just the average.
No customer reviews, ratings, counts, or testimonials found on the R2O VanBuren or Eisenhower 2.0 pages or the DutchCraft Ohio factory site as of Sept 2026. No third-party review aggregates located for this Amish-made DutchCraft line. Complaint themes therefore cannot be verified; generic RTO-channel cautions apply (total lease cost above retail; store-set trial and exchange terms).
Ratings: not published as of Sept 2026.
How we read the reviews
Read each platform on its own: who runs it, its rating scale, how many reviews it has, and the date we checked it.
Reported praise and concerns:
Review sites side by side
What each review site says
Not published
Scroll sideways to see the whole table
Platform
Rating
Sample
Chapter 10
What are the mattresses made of?
Why this matters to you: Layer names say little without numbers. Ask what is inside your exact model, layer by layer.
Eisenhower 2.0 per R2O: copper performance quilt foam (1 inch); copper lumbar support foam (1/2 inch); support foams (1.75 inch and 1/2 inch); 8-inch coil system with reinforced edge; double-sided six-layer 15-inch build. Certifications: CertiPUR-US, GOTS, GOLS, OEKO-TEX, and GREENGUARD status not published as of Sept 2026. Foam densities, coil counts, and cover details beyond the names above: not published as of Sept 2026.
The materials, in plain words
HyPURGel gel foam
Not yet researched
Used in: VanBuren
Copper quilt foam
Not yet researched
Used in: VanBuren
Quantum Edge coils
Not yet researched
Used in: VanBuren
Safety labels, and what each one covers
Certifications
Not yet researched
We have not yet verified DutchCraft's certification claims with the certifiers themselves.
What these labels do and don't prove
Read your law tag
How to read the law tag in three steps
Why this matters to you:
Law tag guide
How to read a mattress law tag
The three steps
1
Not yet researched
2
Not yet researched
3
Not yet researched
Full law tag guide, factory code decoding, and the certificate glossary live on our shared safety page.
How to read this: the law tag, the brand's own statements, and certificates each cover different things. A spec the brand doesn't publish isn't proof it's missing; it just isn't shared.
Chapter 11
Where can you try and buy the mattresses?
Why this matters to you: Where you buy sets the price, the trial and who handles problems. Check the seller's terms, not just the brand's.
Try and buy through rent-to-own dealers: Rent-2-Own carries the line online and in local stores (brand page https://www.r2o.com/brands/dutchcraft plus the Queen VanBuren and Queen Eisenhower 2.0 pages). The factory site (amishmattressfactory.com, 243 Staley Rd, Orwell, OH) offers a Dealer Locator and Become a Dealer page but no direct checkout; model pages show suggested retails only.
Confirm the exact model name, size pricing, and lease terms with the local store before signing.
Showroom Network
Rent-to-own dealers such as Rent-2-Own
Not yet researched
Store Access
Factory in Orwell, OH
Dealer locator, no direct checkout
Sales Culture
Not yet researched
Not yet researched
Inventory & Delivery
Not yet researched
Not yet researched
How to test a bed in the store
Where DutchCraft sells
A sample to show the mix of store types. Use the brand's store finder for the ones near you.
Scroll sideways to see the whole table
#
Channel
Address
Type
1
Orwell, OH
243 Staley Rd, Orwell, OH
Factory
Hours change by location, so call ahead before you visit.
Not yet researched. Checked the R2O DutchCraft brand page.
Chapter 12
DutchCraft vs. other mattress brands
Why this matters to you: A fair comparison needs the same facts for both beds. Line up price, trial and warranty for each one.
Unlike similarly named brands, this DutchCraft (Ohio) line covers only the Amish-made Amish Mattress Factory line sold through rent-to-own dealers; similarly named brands are distinct companies and must not be merged. Vs other RTO-channel beds: DutchCraft wins on the Amish handcrafted story and a double-sided option; loses on published warranty and trial transparency.
Vs mainstream double-sided brands: flippability is shared; DutchCraft loses on review depth and spec disclosure.
Competitor details reflect published prices and specs on the date shown. Mattress brands may update prices and trial terms over time.
Chapter 13
How we research and report
This page is an early draft built from our research sheet for DutchCraft. We read the brand's own pages and public listings, and we do not test mattresses ourselves. Fields marked "Not yet researched" are still being checked.
We researched DutchCraft by fetching the R2O DutchCraft brand page and the Queen VanBuren (53008) and Queen Eisenhower 2.0 (53007) product pages for pricing and layer names (Sept 2026), reading the DutchCraft Mattress (Ohio) factory homepage, mattress-models page, Eisenhower Plush, Obsidian Pillow Top, Autumn Breeze, and Why DutchCraft pages for origin, address, and suggested retails, and checking for reviews, warranties, and certifications.
The Ohio licensee says its diverse team of Amish and non-Amish staff hand-builds mattresses in Orwell, Ohio, and R2O markets the Eisenhower 2.0 as Amish Built.
Which models exist?
VanBuren Luxury Plush Pillowtop, Eisenhower 2.0 Double-Sided, and Obsidian on R2O; Eisenhower Plush, Obsidian Pillow Top, and Autumn Breeze on the factory site.
How much does it cost?
Queen VanBuren and Eisenhower 2.0 retail $1,120 on R2O at $25/week over 78 weeks; factory suggested retails run $1,399 to $2,499.
Is there a sleep trial or warranty?
Neither is published as of Sept 2026; confirm lease, exchange, and warranty terms with the dealer in writing.
Is this the same as Dutch Craft?
No; treat similarly named brands as separate companies.
Prices and promos checked Not yet researched. Recheck before buying.
Find Your Evidence-Backed Match
Need a personalized mattress recommendation?
Answer 6 quick questions about how you sleep, your preferences, and your bed base to compare mattress matches.
